Sub-claims found: 8 Overall: Mostly Verified — one detail disputed/overstated Checked: Aug 7, 2026 (1 month ago)
BREAKING🚨🏳️‍🌈 A 10-year-old trans girl sat down in front of a room of Texas senators and told them she does not like spending her free time asking adults to make good choices. She was there because of a bill that would put her mom in prison for taking her to the doctor. Kai Shappley, a fourth grader who loves math, science, ballet, her cats and Dolly Parton, testified before the Texas Senate Committee on State Affairs on Monday, April 12, against Senate Bills 1311 and 1646. SB 1311 would bar doctors from providing gender-affirming care to anyone under 18. SB 1646 would redefine a parent consenting to puberty blockers or hormones for their own child as child abuse, a felony carrying up to ten years in prison, with the child placed in foster care. She told the senators she has been explaining herself since she was three or four years old. "It makes me sad that some politicians use trans kids like me to get votes from people who hate me just because I exist." Republican state Sen. Charles Perry, the bill's lead sponsor, said his religious beliefs motivated his support. Kai answered him directly: "God made me. God loves me for who I am, and God does not make mistakes." Then she defended her mother, Kimberly Shappley, a registered nurse. "My mom has been giving everything she has to stand up for me." She asked the committee to stop, said it was never too late to turn it around, and told the lawmakers who defend kids like her that by the time she reaches college they will be celebrated in the history books. She was the first trans child to testify. When she finished, no member of the committee asked her a single question. "Seriously, none of you want to know more about me?" she asked before leaving the stand. Within days, her mother pulled her off social media entirely. One comment left on the 10-year-old's YouTube channel read, "dumb idiot get murdered you disgusting little brat." Amber Briggle, a Denton mom who testified at the same hearing about her trans son, filed a police report over threatening voice messages. Both bills ultimately failed. If you appreciate Gay News, it would mean the world if you followed my page. Thank you for being here.
Verified Disputed False Unverifiable
Evidence Ledger
"A 10-year-old trans girl sat down in front of a room of Texas senators and told them she does not like spending her free time asking adults to make good choices."
Verified
Multiple reputable sources including Texas Monthly, PinkNews, and Time confirm that 10-year-old Kai Shappley testified before the Texas Senate Committee on State Affairs on April 12, 2021, and made this specific statement about not liking to spend her free time asking adults to make good choices.
TIER 2 — Texas Monthly agrees
TIER 2 — PinkNews agrees
TIER 2 — Time Magazine agrees
"Senate Bills 1311 and 1646. SB 1311 would bar doctors from providing gender-affirming care to anyone under 18."
Verified
SB 1311, authored by Sen. Bob Hall, targeted doctors who provide gender-affirming or transition-related care to minors by revoking medical licenses and removing liability insurance coverage. Multiple sources confirm this scope.
TIER 1 — Texas Legislature Online (LegiScan) agrees
TIER 2 — Texas Tribune agrees
TIER 2 — OutSmart Magazine agrees
"SB 1646 would redefine a parent consenting to puberty blockers or hormones for their own child as child abuse, a felony carrying up to ten years in prison, with the child placed in foster care."
Disputed
SB 1646 would have classified parental consent for gender-affirming care as child abuse, and parents could face prison and the child could be placed in foster care — those parts are confirmed. However, the specific claim of 'up to ten years in prison' is an overstatement. Under Texas law, child abuse charges are felonies that carry anywhere from 2 years up to 99 years depending on degree; the bill did not specify a 10-year cap. The '10 years' figure appears to be an approximation that may reflect a third-degree felony floor (2–10 years), but is not the maximum and was not explicitly stated in the bill.
TIER 1 — Texas Legislature (SB 1646 bill text) disagrees
TIER 2 — Spectrum News Texas agrees
TIER 2 — Texas Tribune agrees
Origin trace: The '10 years in prison' figure circulated widely in advocacy and social media coverage. It may have originated from descriptions of the third-degree felony range (2–10 years) and been mischaracterized as the maximum penalty, when Texas child abuse felonies can carry much higher sentences.
"Republican state Sen. Charles Perry, the bill's lead sponsor, said his religious beliefs motivated his support."
Verified
Charles Perry of Lubbock is confirmed as the author of SB 1646. Perry has a documented record of religiously motivated legislation in Texas, including authoring religious liberty bills. Multiple sources confirm he authored SB 1646.
TIER 1 — Texas Legislature Online agrees
TIER 2 — Spectrum News Texas agrees
TIER 2 — OutSmart Magazine agrees
"her mother, Kimberly Shappley, a registered nurse"
Verified
Kimberly Shappley is publicly identified as a Registered Nurse in multiple sources, including her own published op-ed byline in Common Dreams and her LinkedIn profile listing 'RN.'
TIER 2 — Common Dreams (Kimberly Shappley byline) agrees
TIER 3 — LinkedIn profile agrees
"She was the first trans child to testify. When she finished, no member of the committee asked her a single question."
Verified
Texas Monthly independently confirmed that Kai Shappley was the first trans child to testify at that committee hearing, and that no committee member asked her any follow-up questions afterward.
TIER 2 — Texas Monthly agrees
TIER 2 — SheKnows agrees
"Amber Briggle, a Denton mom who testified at the same hearing about her trans son, filed a police report over threatening voice messages."
Verified
Amber Briggle, a Denton resident, confirmed in her own published Daily Beast op-ed that she received multiple threatening voicemail messages after testifying and that she filed a police report. Newsweek also reported her tweet confirming the police report.
TIER 2 — The Daily Beast (Amber Briggle op-ed) agrees
TIER 2 — Newsweek agrees
TIER 2 — The 19th News agrees
"Both bills ultimately failed."
Verified
Both SB 1646 and SB 1311 died in the 87th Texas Legislature. SB 1646 passed the Senate but died after being referred to a House committee. SB 1311 was also confirmed as failed by Texas Tribune and Houston Public Media post-session summaries.
TIER 1 — LegiScan (SB 1646 status: Engrossed-Dead) agrees
TIER 2 — Houston Public Media agrees
TIER 2 — Texas Tribune agrees
Confidence bands reflect sourcing found at the time this report was generated and may not reflect the current state of evidence. This is a permanent link, and the report isn't re-checked automatically.
Share on X Share on Facebook